Head-to-head · Updated July 2026

Buffalo Lake Lending vs Northcash

Both are tribal installment lenders charging triple-digit APRs, so this is not a contest of good options — it is about which is less expensive and less risky. Northcash scores higher (2.3 vs 2.1), but the right pick depends on what you need.

Buffalo Lake Lending vs Northcash, side by side: APR, loan amounts, owning tribe, complaints and our editorial score
FeatureBuffalo Lake LendingNorthcash
Our score (/10) 2.1 2.3
APR range 400–795% 716–795%
Loan amounts $200–$2,000 $300–$1,500
Product installment installment
Owning tribe Crow Creek Sioux Tribe Fort Belknap Indian Community
Lending since 2022 2013

Pick Buffalo Lake Lending if…

  • Larger loans available (up to $2,000)
Full Buffalo Lake Lending review

Pick Northcash if…

  • Longer track record (lending since 2013)
  • Higher overall score (2.3 vs 2.1)
Full Northcash review

Our take on each

Buffalo Lake Lending

Search Buffalo Lake Lending and you will find sites offering it at 5.99–35.99% APR. Those sites are typosquats — near-identical domains publishing fake rates to harvest applications. The real lender operates at 400–795%, carries a Washington regulatory alert, and has a complaint on file from a borrower who repaid $1,011.06 on a $640 loan and was told he still owed over $500.

Northcash

Multiple loan-review aggregators report that Northcash has quietly stopped originating new loans — even though its site is still up. If you are searching whether it's still open, the answer appears to be: barely, if at all.

Before choosing either, price a cheaper option. Both loans are last-resort products. A credit-union Payday Alternative Loan is capped at 28% APR, and cash-advance apps cost a fraction of a triple-digit tribal loan. If you already have one of these loans, see our guide to getting out.